Local News
Portage pushes back against rising Manitoba Hydro costs
Portage la Prairie city council is preparing to take its concerns about Manitoba Hydro to the provincial government and the Association of Manitoba Municipalities, after learning the electrical infrastructure required for the city's water treatment plant upgrade could cost millions of dollars. Councillors say the additional expenses represent another financial responsibility being downloaded onto municipalities, with the timing of the request adding to their frustration as the major infrastructure project moves through its planning and design stages. During its latest meeting, council approved an agreement allowing Manitoba Hydro to proceed with detailed design work for a new 66-kilovolt electrical supply line needed for the expanded water treatment plant. The estimated cost for the interconnection work is $538,500, not including the substation. However, the broader electrical infrastructure expenses could reach approximately $5 million. Council questions financial responsibility Deputy Mayor Joe Masi says the additional costs are one of the challenges the city is facing as it works through the water treatment plant upgrade. He says the city is now being asked to take responsibility for the substation, wiring and other electrical infrastructure that would traditionally fall under Manitoba Hydro's responsibilities. “It appears there are other municipalities, but this is a download to our municipality,” Masi said. Masi noted a resolution is being brought forward at the upcoming Association of Manitoba Municipalities convention calling for Manitoba Hydro's policy to be reversed. He says council intends to make its position clear and believes other municipalities facing similar circumstances will support the resolution. “Tonight, we did approve some design work and things. The big dollars are still to come,” Masi said. “We've got to stop this and hopefully we will be successful because I think other municipalities are facing the same issue.” He added that council plans to continue lobbying the province and will raise the issue with senior ministers. Related stories: Portage council faces utility rate decisions, infrastructure spending at Monday meeting Portage seeks federal support for $123-million water project Listen to this news story on the radio: Country 93 / Mix 96 / CFRY 920 Timing adds to frustration Councilor Faron Nichols says the timing of Manitoba Hydro's requirements is another major concern, particularly because the city is already partway through the design and planning process. He says having a significant new expense introduced at this stage makes it more difficult for the city to accurately plan and budget for a project of this size. Nichols also questioned the fairness of having municipalities take on additional infrastructure requirements after they have already begun working through project designs and cost estimates. Administration explained that some electrical infrastructure costs had been anticipated in the original planning. However, the city's engineering consultants had identified what they believed would be the most reasonable and practical route for the supply line. Manitoba Hydro requested a different route, which significantly increased the estimated cost. As a result, although the city had allocated some funding for the electrical work, the original allowance was nowhere near the amount now being projected. More costs could still come The current $538,500 estimate covers the interconnection work and does not include the substation. Masi said the substation and transmission line alone could account for approximately $600,000, while the broader Hydro-related costs could reach roughly $5 million. The city's portion of the current interconnection estimate is expected to be split equally between the provincial grant and the utility reserve, with approximately $269,250 coming from each. Council's approval allows Manitoba Hydro to move ahead with detailed design work, but additional costs and agreements will still be required before construction can proceed. Mayor Sharilyn Knox has also indicated the city intends to bring the issue to the provincial government, arguing that municipalities need clearer direction on their financial responsibilities when major infrastructure projects require additional electrical work. Masi says council will not stop advocating for a reversal of the policy, adding that the city wants to send a strong message that municipalities should not be expected to absorb these unexpected costs.